The Mets get hammered in this town for a multitude of offenses and in most instances, the bludgeoning is warranted but when it comes to the decision by J-Man to work Jose Reyes into the 3 spot of the lineup, the criticism is not only unwarranted but it’s also senseless.

In today’s NY Post, avid Mets hater Joel Sherman (there are lot’s of Mets haters in MSM, Jon Heyman, Bill Madden, Tom Verducci and of course their Emperor Mike Francesa) has a full page column today take the Met to task for batting Reyes third, even though he admits it’s out of necessity and just something Manuel pulled out of his ass:

 The shift is a reaction to Carlos Beltran’s knee surgery, which will cost him at least a month of the season. Without Beltran to hit third, Manuel fears the lineup lacks length if he simply has David Wright bat third and Jason Bay fourth. The order would dip precipitously at No. 5, likely with Daniel Murphy. In addition, Manuel wants to preserve Reyes’ legs and feels batting him third will translate to fewer steal attempts to limit the risk of having runners thrown out in front of your best RBI men, Wright and Bay.

Sherman goes on in the article to give his hypothesis on why this is bad idea, but gives no solution, which of course there isn’t any. If Carlos Beltran were of sound mind and knee, this would not even be an issue but as we know the best laid plans of mice and Mets never go as planed and so they have this situation to make the best of the lineup until Beltran gets back.

Sherman lays out the answer to the why part of Reyes hitting third when he mentions Daniel Murphy hitting fifth. Murphy is not a #5 hitter. He’s a perfect #2 but the problem is Luis Castillo is also a perfect #2. And there is the problem; the Mets have two #2 and two #1 in Reyes and Angel Pagan.

From the rumbling’s from St. Lonesome, Beltran is progressing nicely and should just miss just the first month of the season (I know, I know you’ll believe it when you see it) so when he comes back Reyes moves back to the #1 spot and Beltran back to #3 and the team will live happily ever after. I hope.

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter


  1. Steve,

    The fine journalists mentioned above as well as myself are not Shake Shack haters. We simply offer a different, but ultimately a more positive slant about Citiville.

    Meanwhile, it might help The Great White Hope (Murphy) to be dropped in the lineup. Maybe, whatever skills he has can be better developed batting lower. I cite Robinson Cano. (The Great White Hope should only be sooo good.) This can be effectuated once the lineup is at full tilt. “We” can’t afford Murphy’s atrocious on base rate batting # 2.

  2. kranepool says:

    Michael your getting close to Sherman-Madden-Verducci territory

  3. Michael says:


    Oh c’mon Steve.

    I’m on your side when you need a friend and friends just can’t be found…….

  4. Ronnie was on with Boomer and Carton this morning, and he said Reyes at number 3 is a bad idea. I’m watching my TiVo of the game, and Keith agrees. Ronnie’s point is Reyes leading off is one of the few “knowns” on the team. Why mess with that? My point is the guy missed almost all of last season, so why put him at 3 and then back to leadoff? He needs to get comfortable again in his place, not be bounced around. Also, Boomer went off while talking to Ronnie. He has had it with Jerry’s comedy routine. He says people pay a lot of money to watch this team, how about some focus and determination? Leave the comedy to Seinfeld and act like you give a shit. Ronnie added that athletes need to be led, and he was not sure they get that on this team. Right on, Ronnie. One more reason a large broom should have come out of the closet in October.

  5. kranepool says:

    my only question is with Beltran out then who bats 3rd? With Pagan leading off you still get descent OBP with some pop and speed I think what everyone is forgetting here this move isn’t on a whim and it’s only until Beltran comes back

Speak Your Mind



The Mets are looking great this year and The Eddie Kranepool Society keeps you up to date on the good bad and the ugly. If you are looking for Mets Tickets, you must visit Coast To Coast Tickets for all your ticket needs. CTC carries MLB Tickets as well as some of the best priced Concert Tickets on the web and don't forget they also carry Yankees Tickets.

Visit BangTheBook.Com for daily free MLB Mets Picks and gameday previews, also join the baseball handicapping discussion in the forum or track your plays in our sports monitor.